Hark! The Herald Angels Sing – Weezer
Jesus Christ – Elephant Micah
Gaudete – The Mediaeval Baebes
Handel’s Messiah – Reliant K
Love Came Down At Christmas – Jars of Clay
Joy To The World – Sufjan Stevens
Once In Royal David’s City – Sufjan Stevens
What Child Is This – Matt Wertz
Greensleeves – Vince Guaraldi Trio
Winter Song (with Ingrid Michaelson) – Sarah Barelles
O Come O Come Emmanuel – Sufjan Stevens
Angels We Have Heard On High – Sixpence None The Richer
I Heard The Bells on Christmas Day – Jars of Clay
Cry Cry Christmas – The Sweptaways
O Holy Night – Weezer
We Three Kings – Sufjan Stevens
Christmas Time Is Here – Vince Guaraldi Trio
Angels We Have Heard On High – Josh Wilson
Silent Night/Away In A Manger – Reliant K
I Saw Three Ships – Sufjan Stevens
It Came Upon A Midnight Clear – Sixpence None The Richer
Archives
Search
Meta
Not So Fast 
Listen to “I Heard The Bells on Christmas Day” by Casting Crowns, I think it is a better version than the JoC. I had never heard this hymn until the other day and was just blown away by it.
Also, “I Celebrate the Day” is a must.
I sampled the Casting Crowns version but it’s a little too country for me.
Plus I hate to add to their overexposure right now.